Renegade-Hamster's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Learn to draw backgrounds]

No offense...

... but your backgrounds aren't that great, and that affects the quality of this tutorial.

Keep working on it.

You've done an okay job with making the interface (buttons and such). Is this your first flash?

1/5

autowepon responds:

meh i guess they werent amazing but i am starting to draw better things like i said in another reveiw i started a thread on it. come on over and see it.

[Fast Ball]

Copy and paste job

You've obviously downloaded the required code from the internet and then injected it into your own flash file to make a game. I could have done that.

You didn't work out the code yourself, the graphics are simple, and the game is boring. You get no mark.

0/5

poccer2 responds:

Yes sir!!!

thanxz foe advice(comment, watever)
poccer2

[Advanced LightSaber Tut]

Before you do a tutorial...

It's probably best to do a search with the search engine available on this site for any that are like it.

There are MANY lightsabre tutorials on Newgrounds, and making another one would be redundant.

This was okay and it said a lot of the things people need to know when making a lightsabre, but I would hardly call it advanced. You have not included what sounds to add and when, you haven't talked about other effects (such as a throbbing glow of the blade, a glowing ball of light near the handle, lightsabre clashing effects, etc), some of the graphics are shocking (the little man, sabre handles, no backgrounds), and I think you could have included a nice little example animation to show what it's supposed to look like when it's done.

Good music choice. Good, dramatic stuff from Star Wars.

But on a whole, this tutorial is redundant and not as good as it could have been.

1/5

tyLen0L responds:

Sorry,but if you not have seen the ATTENTION Frame saying that i gonna do the other lightsaber effects that you showed in your review in another tut named Star Wars Effects Tutorial =).

[Super Marco, Level 005]

It was okay

I have no idea how to script these things, so I've got some respect for people who do.

Everything about this is good (graphics, music. etc) except it was way too easy.

Because of that, I didn't really enjoy playing. Sorry.

2/5

Bofred responds:

pah 2/5 for 1 1/2 years scripting work, thanks

[Foamy: CarAndCellphoneAds]

Actually, I found this funny

Could have been much better with some good graphics, (Not the actual drawings you did and said to add colour to make it look real. That's part of the humour). With the images you downloaded, cut them out properly. It just looks really crappy how you've done it. e.g. Germaine image.

Might also have been better with a background other than plain white.
Maybe you could have downloaded an image off google and traced it!

I still kinda liked this. It's not like Illwillpress hasn't been made fun of before, but you made some original ways of expressing your gripes with him.

2/5

Sorry you have to put up with the Foamheads. I like Foamy as well, but I have enough brains to know most of Illwill's toons are crappy, so I'm not going to swear my lungs out at you.

hamandcheeseclock responds:

thanks. Finaly a good review. Also germaine was like that porposly.

[SS - Ultimate Quiz]

The quiz doesn't work

It wouldn't let me see the first question.

Test things before you submit them.

0/5

MushroomT responds:

shut up.

[Dragonslayer v1.2]

Meh

Good graphics and great action scripting, but the gameplay was pretty boring, and there was no way to defend myself. I slowly, but surely, died and decided it wasn't worth playing again.

Sorry.

2/5

thewasteofwebspace responds:

You can defend yourself by holding your mouse over an incoming fireball and tapping space. of course, you would have known that too if you read the instructions.

~TheWaste

[Islam At Glance]

An okay submission

Good information on what Muslims believe, good format, and good graphics. I don't really like that kind of singing, but it was atmospheric at least.

I have some questions, though.

(1) Have you read the Quran? If so, what parts?

(2) Doesn't the Quran teach Muslims to kill the infidel (unbeliever)?

I know the vast majority of Muslims do not believe in that, but then again, it seems the vast majority of Muslims put their Quran at the highest part of the house (perhaps above a bookcase, covered in an expensive cloth) and never read it.

Would it be right for me to say that to claim that Islam is a religion of peace is a lying? Rather that most Muslims are not well versed in the Islamic texts and merely decide from their own opinion that they will not try to harm Western society?

Please respond carefully and intelligently, the same way as your flash is set out. I don't want to be accused of being an ignorant red-neck, because I know quite a bit about the basics of Islam. I already knew the information this flash presents plus a little more.

2/5

Flashawy responds:

I have read the Quran tens of times and ofcourse all of it,not just that I even memorize 9 parts of it..!!
i am sure that you didn't read the quran, but it looks like you have read about that from a non-muslim author or something like that...
then it will be fair to judge islam after knowing what islam says about killing and attacks...
islam never says to kill unbeliever because he didn't belive in islam..this really rediciolus...i am from Egypt,in my country there are mora than 9 millions of christians,and if you know that islam entered egypt from about 1350 years ago...why there is such amount of christians in the islamworld...didn't islam should have killed them ?

don't repeat what you hear about isdlam blindly without thinking about it...
any way, i have prepared a very detailed answer about your questions and some other questions that people ask about islam such as:
-what the quran says about Jihad and the holy war and terror and killing unbelievers ?
-what is the real status of women in islam?
and some other things..originally i was asked about these from a christian guy called chris,but after replying him i have uploaded the reply to my server to enable many people to access it,here it is:
http://flashandy.com/DetailedReply.htm

now please take your time reading this,and after you finish come to me to discuss it...it is not fair to judge a religion with what you hear from its enemies??!!